Bethpage and New York Public Golf: Courses and How to Book
This page contains affiliate links. If you buy through one, Golf Toolbox may earn a commission.
Bethpage State Park on Long Island gives you a U.S. Open course at a public-course price, and that combination is why a tee time there takes planning. The park has five 18-hole courses: Black, Red, Blue, Green and Yellow. Our listings cover the first four. Beyond Bethpage, New York has a strong set of public and resort courses upstate and at the eastern end of Long Island. Green fees in our New York listings run from about $30 to $195 for the courses in this guide, and they move with the season and, at the state park courses, with where you live. Confirm rates and access when you book.
Bethpage Black
Bethpage Black in Farmingdale is the course with the warning sign by the first tee, which says the Black Course is an extremely difficult course recommended only for highly skilled golfers. Take it seriously. Our listing shows a 77.5 course rating and a 155 slope, the highest numbers of any course in this guide. The Black hosted the U.S. Open in 2002 and 2009, the 2019 PGA Championship and the 2025 Ryder Cup, and it is still a New York State park course that the public can book.
Fees run about $75 to $150 in our listings, and New York residents pay less than out-of-state players. The Black is walking-only and the ground is hilly, so plan for a long, tiring 18 holes on foot. You can check tee times at Bethpage Black through our listing.
A 155 slope pushes your course handicap well above your index, so a round here can look worse on the card than it really was. Our handicap tracker does that math for you, and our guide to understanding your handicap index explains how slope feeds into it.
What booking Bethpage takes
Getting on the Black is the hard part. New York residents can register with the state park reservation system and get a longer advance booking window than non-residents, and the prime weekend times go almost as soon as they open. Out-of-state golfers face a shorter window and higher fees. The Black has also long kept some times for walk-up play, and golfers famously wait in the parking lot overnight, sleeping in their cars, for a chance at one. The rules have changed over the years, so check the current reservation policy with the park before you plan a trip around it.
A few habits improve your odds. Weekdays are far easier than weekends. Afternoon times open up more often than mornings. Have a backup booked on another Bethpage course the same day, so the trip is not wasted if the Black falls through. Single golfers can sometimes join an open spot in a group, so ask at the starter if you are on site.
Red, Blue and Green
If the Black is sold out, the other Bethpage courses are worth playing on their own terms.
Bethpage Red is an A.W. Tillinghast design that many regulars rate as the toughest test in the park after the Black, and it is often available when the Black is not. Fees run about $45 to $79 in our listings. You can book a tee time on the Red as your backup or as the main event.
Bethpage Blue is a strong layout that tends to be overshadowed by the Black, at about $45 to $79. Bethpage Green is a Devereux Emmet design and the gentlest of the four in our data, with fees of about $30 to $55 and a 122 slope. It is the cheapest round in this guide and a good choice for a mixed group. The Yellow course is not in our listings yet.
Montauk Downs and the east end
Montauk Downs State Park sits near the tip of Long Island. Robert Trent Jones Sr. redesigned it in a links style, the ocean breeze is part of the test, and fees run about $40 to $84. It is another state park course, so check whether resident rates apply when you book. You can book Montauk Downs through our listing.
National Golf Links of America and The Maidstone Club are also out on the east end and appear in our data, but both are private clubs, so this guide does not include them.
Upstate New York
Saratoga National in Saratoga Springs is a Roger Rulewich design with wetlands and mature hardwoods. Fees run about $59 to $125 and the slope is 139, and it pairs well with a summer visit to the town. Check tee times at Saratoga National for your dates.
Leatherstocking in Cooperstown is the Devereux Emmet course at the Otesaga Hotel on Otsego Lake, with lakeside finishing holes. It is a resort course at about $55 to $99, and it fits easily into a trip to the Baseball Hall of Fame. You can book Leatherstocking here.
Atunyote at Turning Stone in Verona is a Tom Fazio design at the casino resort, with rolling terrain and a 143 slope. At about $95 to $195, it is the priciest course in this guide. Resort guests have typically paid a lower rate than outside players, so compare a stay-and-play package with a single round before you book. Find a tee time at Atunyote if you want a resort round in central New York.
Seneca Hickory Stick in Lewiston, near Niagara Falls, is a Robert Trent Jones Jr. design on open meadow terrain near the Niagara Escarpment. Fees run about $35 to $59, which makes it the best value upstate. Book Seneca Hickory Stick for a stop on a Niagara trip.
Closer to the city, Pound Ridge Golf Club in Westchester County is a public Pete Dye design with big rock outcroppings and a 147 slope, at about $69 to $145.
Planning your New York rounds
Treat Bethpage as a booking project. Register early if you are a resident, aim for a weekday and keep a backup on the Red, Blue or Green. Upstate courses are far easier to book and cheaper, so a trip that pairs one Bethpage day with two or three upstate rounds keeps both cost and stress down.
The Black punishes missed fairways and long approaches, and the right setup helps. Our club fitting tool can point you toward a driver, irons and shafts that suit your swing speed. For more options, browse the course finder by state.
Start with the Black's booking window, then check the backup courses on our tee times page the same day so you have a round either way.
Ready to improve your game?
Use our free tools to get personalized recommendations and track your progress.