·Golf Toolbox Team

Blade vs Mallet Putter: How to Choose by Stroke Type

This page contains affiliate links. If you buy through one, Golf Toolbox may earn a commission.

The simplest way to choose between a blade and a mallet putter is to match the putter's balance to the shape of your stroke. If your putter head swings on an arc, opening on the way back and closing through impact, a blade with toe hang usually suits you. If your stroke moves the head more or less straight back and straight through, a face-balanced mallet usually fits better. Looks and feel matter too, but they come second.

Find Your Stroke Shape First

Most golfers putt with some arc. The putter shaft sits at an angle to the ground, so a natural stroke travels on a gentle curve around your body, and the face rotates open and closed relative to the target line as it goes. The amount varies a lot. Some players have a strong arc with plenty of face rotation. Others keep the head close to the target line and feel almost no rotation.

You can check yours without any special equipment. Lay a club or alignment stick on the ground parallel to your target line, just outside the ball. Make practice strokes of different lengths and watch the toe of the putter. If the toe swings away from the stick going back and returns toward it through impact, you have an arc. If the head tracks the stick closely on both sides, your stroke is closer to straight back and through. A phone video taken from behind your hands, looking down the line, shows the same thing.

Toe Hang Versus Face Balanced

Balance is the spec that connects putter design to stroke shape. Rest the shaft on your finger with the head hanging free. If the face points at the sky, the putter is face balanced. If the toe drops toward the ground, it has toe hang, and the further the toe drops, the more toe hang it has.

Face-balanced putters resist rotating during the stroke. That helps a player who wants the face to stay square to the line the whole way. Toe-hang putters want to rotate a little, opening on the backswing and closing through the ball, which matches an arcing stroke. When the balance fights your stroke, you end up manipulating the face with your hands to get it square, and that shows up as pushed and pulled putts that start off line.

The hosel, or neck, drives most of this. A plumber's neck on a classic blade usually produces moderate toe hang. Shorter necks and slants change the amount. Double-bend shafts and center-shafted designs are common ways to get face balance. Many models ship with more than one neck option, so check the hosel on the exact version you are buying, not only the head name.

The Blades: Newport 2 and Anser

Blade putters have a narrow head with most of the weight spread toward the heel and toe. They give clear feedback, so a mishit feels like a mishit, and they suit players who like to feel the face rotate.

The Scotty Cameron Super Select Newport 2 is the classic example. In our catalog it lists around $450 and is milled from 303 stainless steel, with a forgiveness rating of 6 out of 10. That rating tells you what you are trading. You get feedback and clean lines, and you give up some stability on putts struck away from the center of the face. Our skill ratings place it from intermediate through scratch.

The Ping PLD Milled Anser is the shape the Newport family descends from. Ping's original Anser set the template for the heel-toe weighted blade that most brands still copy. The PLD Milled version is fully milled from 303 stainless steel and lists around $475 in our catalog, with a forgiveness rating of 7. If you like a blade but want slightly more help on mishits, compare these two side by side.

Both suit arcing strokes. If you have a clear arc and a good feel for the face, start with these two.

The Mallets: Spider Tour X and 2-Ball

Mallets have larger heads that push weight away from the face and out toward the perimeter. That raises the moment of inertia, or MOI, which is how much the head resists twisting when you miss the center. On a putt struck toward the toe, a high-MOI mallet loses less ball speed and the face turns less, so the ball finishes closer to the line and closer to the right distance.

The TaylorMade Spider Tour X is built around that idea. Our catalog describes it as a high-MOI mallet with heavy tungsten weighting and TaylorMade's True Path alignment. It lists around $400 with a forgiveness rating of 8, and our skill ratings place it from beginner through low handicap.

The Odyssey Ai-ONE 2-Ball CH carries the highest forgiveness rating of these four at 9. It pairs the 2-Ball alignment design with a face pattern Odyssey designed to even out ball speed across the face, and it lists around $350. Our ratings place it from beginner through mid handicap.

Mallets often suit straighter strokes because many of them are face balanced. Do not treat that as automatic. Some mallets come with toe hang on purpose, for players with an arc who still want a forgiving head, so read the hosel spec before you buy.

How Alignment Aids Work

Plenty of missed short putts start before the stroke. If the face is aimed off line at address, a good stroke still misses. Alignment aids help you see where the face points.

Blades usually have a single sight line or a small dot on the top line. Some players find that a clean top line helps them square the face because there is little to distract the eye. Mallets use larger shapes. The 2-Ball design uses two circles the size of a golf ball, which lets you frame the ball behind them. True Path on the Spider Tour X uses lines that run back through the head. Players who struggle to aim often find longer lines easier to read.

A simple test helps. Set up to a short, straight putt, aim the face, then have a friend check where it points with an alignment stick laid against the face. Repeat with a few putters. The one you aim most accurately is worth more to you than the one that looks best on the rack.

Feel, Weight and Length

Head weight changes how the stroke feels. A heavier head tends to steady a handsy stroke, while a lighter head gives more sense of where the head is on long putts. Length matters just as much. A putter that is too long pushes your eyes inside the ball and your hands up, and that changes both your aim and your arc. Most putters can be cut down or extended by a club fitter, so do not reject a head because the stock length is wrong.

Face construction also changes sound and feel. A fully milled steel face like the Newport 2 or the Anser tends to sound firmer than a face with an insert. Sound is a matter of preference, so trust your ears.

Before You Buy

Do the stick test at home first and write down what you see, because a shop green is a poor place to discover your stroke shape. At the store, ask to roll one toe-hang blade and one face-balanced mallet cut to your length. Hit ten putts of about six feet with each toward the same hole and count how many start on the line you chose, not how many drop. Start line is where a mismatch in balance shows up first, so that count tells you which one your stroke prefers. Our gear reviews cover the rest of the bag once the putter is settled.

Ready to improve your game?

Use our free tools to get personalized recommendations and track your progress.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.